Lead · Power shifts to your competitors
The easy business goes first.
AI can now quote and bind simple policies in minutes, with no agent involved. Carriers selling direct and AI-native rivals aim first at standard accounts, because those need the least advice and are the easiest to take.
The line between easy and hard business is where your future book lives. McKinsey expects AI to cut agents out fastest in commoditized personal lines. In midmarket commercial and specialty lines, it expects AI to make good brokers more productive, not replace them.
So move toward the business AI can't easily serve: up-market accounts, policies with warts, deep niches, and clients who choose you because they value what you have to offer and trust you.
Evidence
- The Hartford says it quotes over 75% of new small business policies from admitted markets with no human involved, and has added a buy button to its small business quote flow.[1]
- Travelers' Simply Business quotes small businesses inside ChatGPT from three inputs: business type, revenue and ZIP code.[2]
- Where judgment matters, agents still win. They place 87.7% of commercial premium, but only 39.5% of personal lines.[3]
- McKinsey expects disintermediation to move fastest in commoditized personal lines. In midmarket commercial and specialty, AI is more likely to boost broker productivity than replace advisers.[4]
How to do it
- 1Segment your book by line, account complexity and how much advice each segment really needs.
- 2Defend where expertise wins: commercial, niche and complex accounts. Independent agents still place 87.7% of commercial lines premium.[4]
- 3Automate service on the simple accounts you keep, so they stay profitable as prices fall.
- 4Exit, or stop chasing, pure-price business, and give that capacity to growth.
- 5Decide this quarter. Speed is now a competitive position in itself.
“We were a 6 million-dollar agency back then… Today, we're pushing on a hundred million dollars in premium… You can't argue with that kind of success and I credit most of it to Michael Jans.”
What it means
The easier an account is to quote, the easier it is to lose. Your future book is the business that needs you, not another free quote. Go deep on value, expertise, trust and relationship.
Where to play
Which parts of my client base and book are most vulnerable to AI-driven competition? Where could I go deeper: up-market, policies with warts, or a niche?
How to win
What would make those clients choose me because they value what I offer and trust me, not because I'm the cheapest quote?
Try this
Identify the simplest 20% of my book and decide for each group: deepen, bundle or let go.
Sources
- 1.Hartford adds buy button to small business flow (opens in a new tab)Coverager, citing The Hartford's 2026 shareholder letter
- 2.Agentic AI in small commercial: quote-to-bind in minutes (opens in a new tab)actuary.info
- 3.Independent agency market share, 2025 (opens in a new tab)Insurance Journal, on the Big "I" Market Share Report
- 4.AI could break insurance's two-decade growth stalemate, McKinsey says (opens in a new tab)Risk & Insurance, July 23, 2026